***Minor Spoilers***
We finally made it to the third book in the An Ember in the Ashes series and things are getting real. Laia, Elias and Helena are basically on their own as they deal with the many crisis’ going on in the Empire. Laia is focused on one two things, bringing down the Nightbringer and saving her people. Elias is the new Soul Catcher but having trouble in his new role. Helena is the Blood Shrike, trying to defend the Empire and the Emperor who she doesn’t like and defending what is left of their family. As they go about their business, they have no idea that they are doing exactly what the Nightbringer wants them to do. It frustrating as it is interesting to read as the reader knows that the characters are playing into their enemies hands but are unsure as to how exactly and horrified that they is nothing they can do about it. I spent a fair amount of my time reading wanting to scream at Laia, Elias and Helena to STOP WHAT YOU ARE DOING! YOU ARE MAKING A DUMB MISTAKE! Especially, Helena who was supposed to be one of the smartest in her class at the Blackcliff but time and time again was easily out maneuvered by The Commandant or the Nightbringer. He biggest mistake is that she assumes that everyone loves the Empire as much as she does and will play fair and is shocked to find that’s not the case and even though she is told this many times she continues to make this mistake. (I think a certain political party is the same way and is why it keeps losing) Her unwillingness to believe or play that game keeps costing her and is even more frustrating because the one time she does, she won. Anyway, this was a great set up to the final book that will definitely feature more pain. Let’s hope our characters learn from their mistakes in this book.
A satisfying ending to a very good series. It starts just minutes after the end of King’s Cage, where Mare is reeling from being betrayed by Cal choosing the crown over her. I wasn’t really all that surprised by this because as much as he loves Mare and has been open to the red plight but he is a Silver Prince that was born to rule. He’s going to give that up? Anyway, Victoria does a great job of balancing her Game of Thronesque story lines. With so many families, groups and countries vying for the future of Norta the story could have been easily bogged down but it isn’t. Alliances are clear and who is going to betray who is clear. We all know who is on what team and when it comes down to it who is going to side with who when it comes to the end it didn’t disrupt the storyline. At the moment, Mare and Cal are reunited in the same objective of get Maven out of power but their alliance is shaky at best. We know that Cal has no intention of giving up his throne as he feels he is the best to reunite his fractured nation but the Scarlet Guard has no intention of putting him on the throne. Maven has the Nortan crown but little support. Iris, his wife from neighboring country the Lakelands, is already scheming to take the crown from Maven as soon as he depletes his army against Cal. The western nation of Montfort that is the only democracy in this new world that has silvers and reds working together has made their intentions known that they will not have another silver king either. So who wins? Well that would be too spoilery but I will say i like the ambiguous ending. Victoria has definitely left enough open that if she ever wanted to return to Norta, Monfort or the Lakelands she could but if she doesn’t then she has given her characters a good send off. Mare is broken and bruised but is working on healing. She has been many people throughout the four books. She’s been Mare from the sticks, a thief. She’s been Mareena, a lost Silver and the lightning girl a leader and inspiration for the rebellion but who is she really. Cal’s growth is quite as strong but then again I think Cal has already had a good sense of who he was. Maven is probably the most tragic. The abuse that he suffered from his mother is beyond cruel but that shouldn’t excuse his many crimes he committed throughout the series. My biggest complaint is that Cameron who was one of POV characters in the last book only makes an appearance in one chapter. Other than that, this was a satisfying ending to a very good series.
The final book in the Talon Saga was kinda of a disappointment in the sense that I didn’t really love it only liked it. It took a really long time to get going and for the final book the lack of urgency was a strange. The characters kept telling each other about how the end is coming soon but really didn’t seem to be in much of a hurry to prepare for it until they had no choice to and then things Finally got going. But damn, we had to go through a lot of things to get there. There was the unnecessary trip to Brazil to meet an ancient dragon that was never mentioned before and there was another trip to Asia for the that we all knew how it would end up. There were past mentioned characters showing up and taking up time for no reason but fit in one more heroic arc? I don’t know. The finale however was worth it though. The final battle between the Rogues, St. George and Talon made up the lackluster beginning. It had drama, suspense and melodrama all wrapped into one. I appreciate the theme of the series being that even though we may be different, what we all want out of life is the same. We want to live in peace and have freedom of choice. And authoritative governments are bad. The best way to bring down an oppressive regime is to overcome our differences and work together and learn from each other. I very important message for today. That’s what you should take away from this series in the end. I just wished the last book wasn’t so bogged down in so many side trips.
I received this as an ARC a month ago. Thank you to the publisher for making it available.
I liked this one a little better than Carve the Mark. I think maybe because the world was more established and the complicated relationship between each character was more set. Also opening up the universe to new planets made and introducing more characters with darker skin as more than just warriors or brutal dictators also helped. That doesn’t make some of the character development any less problematic but I do think that Veronica Roth listened to the criticism of the first one and took that into account while writing this one. I’m also grateful that this is only a duology and not a trilogy. Knowing that this was the last book, I felt the pacing was better, the story more concise loose ends tied up. That being said, she did leave an opening to return to this world if she wanted to but I’m happy with how it ended.