What were your favorite books this year?

The end of 2025 is coming soon. (Thank Goodness!) It’s that time of the year when Kate and I start thinking about the books we liked the most this year. Before we post our lists, we were wondering, what our your favorite books you read in 2025? Drop them in the comments and let’s see which ones we all liked and which ones we need to add for 2026.

Review: Alchemy of Secrets by Stephanie Garber

**Contains some Spoilers**

This book started off so intensely and then lost steam. Holland is a graduate student. I can’t even remember if she is pursuing her Master’s or a PhD. I don’t think they even say what for. Only something to do with myths and urban legends. Her professor teaches a secret class about urban legends that may be true, and Holland is her best student. One night, she decides to go down a shady alley in search of one of the legends and brings along someone she is dating. The next day, she is called in to meet the new professor, Adam Bishop, who tells her that Professor is no longer her mentor and is a liar. Then the guy she was dating dies at the exact time the legend tells him, and she only has 24 hours to live. She can prolong her life if she finds the Alchemical Heart that no one has ever seen or knows what it looks like or knows where it is. Enters Gabe, a random guy who deactivates her car and says her twin sister sent him to protect her. They start to follow clues that lead them to a mysterious bank that is also part of a legend from her class. She finds out that her professor runs the bank and needs her to give her the heart once she finds it. Oh, and Gage may have killed his wife for powers. So she runs away from Gabe and runs into Adam, who also says that he was sent by her sister to protect her. And off they go following clues until the big reveal at the end. It’s roughly around the time that Holland starts searching with Adam that I felt the lack of urgency that was in the first half of the book. I can’t say why, I felt that way, but yeah. Things start to slow down for me. Not to spoil too much, but the resolution left some questions. It never really answered why Gabe was looking for the heart or what happened between him and his wife. Like, why bring it up and all? We never find out which one her sister sent to help her, if any, or what her sister’s role is in all of this. She is obviously part of this world, but it feels like she is pulling more of the strings than anything else. It wasn’t a bad book, but it just left me unsatisfied. It started out so good. I just wish it could have kept up the momentum.

What I’m Reading Now: Red City by Marie Lu

This month’s theme is Fall into Family. I’m stretching the theme a bit because this is only kind of about family, since the Mob is a family, right? You never go against the family? Anywho, this is Marie Lu’s adult novel debut. I’m sure it’s going to be as good as her YA novels.

Review: Accomplice to the Villain by Hannah Nicole Maehrer

I am so glad I found this series because it continues to entertain me. It is funny, charming, and all the characters are so damn likable. I can’t get enough of the back and forth between Evie and Trystan. I cheered when Becky finally kissed Blade and then immediately ran off. lol. I am glad that we got more of Kingston and his story. It was just a treat to read. We begin not that long after the last book ends. King Benedict has taken one of the Guyvre’s needed to fulfill the prophecy, and Trystan’s magic is going haywire every time he is around Evie. Evie and Lyssa are coping with the return of their once-thought-dead mother. There are a lot of feelings going around. As there should be. A lot has happened to our beloved Villain and his crew. It still amuses me that he runs his villainous empire as any other corporate company with HR and finance teams. He may be the Villain, but he does know how to take care of people. Something that Trystan is just discovering he has been doing all along, but now he is discovering he actually cares. To save the magic, they must figure out the prophecy that they don’t know, but King Benedict does. Hijinks ensue. Twists and turns happen, and oh boy, did we get a fun ending. I thought this was a trilogy, but we are getting at least another book. Which is great because I am not ready to leave these crazy characters.

Quick Review: The Fallen and the Kiss of Dusk by Carissa Broadbent

In the ultimate sacrifice, Mische saves Asar, making him a half God and starting off an eternal night. Of course, they are the only people who can fix it. This time, they have to find God artifacts above ground and well, they are sort of successful. They make many more enemies. I do love the chemistry between Mische and Asar. They just fit each other. It was also nice to get some time with Raihn and Oraya. The couple that started this whole thing. The pacing of this book was a little inconsistent. The last section, at first, felt out of place to me, but I eventually saw what she was doing. I thought this was the last of the books, but apparently, there are more. They didn’t fix things as much as they created more problems for everyone. Not to mention the Gods of the White Pantheon are kind of dicks. Fun book. A good bridge book to the next installment of the series.

What I’m Reading Now: Accomplice to the Villain by Hannah Nicole Maehrer

October’s book club this month is “Heroes who are actually the villain”. Inspired by Columbus Day. I couldn’t find a book on my TBR that fit the bill, so I decided to go with this one. In the world of the series, our main characters are seen to be the villain’s but in truth, they are the heroes. True, one does use his interns as target practice, but still, the good guy.

Review: The Dark Mirror by Samantha Shannon

Five books in, and I truly believe this series keeps getting better. At the end of the last book, we were left with uncertainty as to what would happen to Paige next. In this book, Paige does not know where she is or who she is with. She has to escape, and thank goodness, she knows how to take care of herself because she immediately finds Maria and safety. She finds herself first in Poland, then in Czechia, and then eventually in Italy. She is for the first time outside of Scion, and we, as the readers, get our first glimpse of the world outside of Scion, but also what the resistance to their spreading influence is like. We were already introduced to Domino in the last book, but we get even more info on how the organization is run. Despite Paige being in the “free world,” she is not safe. Scion has put out a bounty on her, and new organizations want her, too. Paige, however, is focused on finding out what happened to her over the last couple of months and finding Warden. Finding Warden is paramount to the plot because not only is he the key to helping Paige restore her memories, but Italy is being threatened by Scion from within, and they need his knowledge to stop it. I won’t go too much more into the plot so as not to spoil anything, but I love seeing the expansion of the world. Paige is such a good character. She has this powerful gift, but what makes her the most effective is her street smarts. She knows how to navigate the world by using her own knowledge and instincts. Her powers help, but even when she doesn’t have them, she is still dangerous. Which is really why Scion and other organizations want her. They know how dangerous she is. They have seen how she can get people to rally behind her and fight. With only two more books to go in the series, we are only now seeing the true potential of Paige. Scion knows it, and now Paige knows it, too.