I am not sure how I feel about this book and this series. It’s not that I didn’t like it because I did. I wouldn’t have read the sequel if I had not but there is something about it that…I’m not sure how to explain. I thought maybe of Jade and Dragons it was the narrator of the audiobook that took me out of some moments but I still had trouble connecting with this one as well. So I guess it is the writing. I don’t know. The Book Phoenix takes place about two years after the end of Of Jade and Dragons. Ying is now living in a new village and engaged to a son of Chieftain and Ye-Yang is still the Head Commander. I am still unsettled about how things ended between the two at the end of the last book. With Ye-Yang promising he would come back for her because he doesn’t dream of things, he always gets what he wants. Can we say red flag? In the last book, there were mentions of pirates roaming the sees and the threat to the Nine Isles but now those threats are much more dangerous. They are attacking shipments and have decimated the Antarian fleet. The country has taken a lot of refugees from the Empire, putting more restrain on their resources. Something has to be done. Ying may have walked a way from the Engineer’s Guild but she still continues to create. She has developed the “Octopus” a submarine of sorts. She built it as a means to leave the country but it can be helpful against the pirates. Things change when the pirates, specifically the most feared ship the Blood Phoenix attacks her new home and kills her fiancée. Ye-Yang comes to her for help. He has been keeping tabs on her and knows that she has created something that could turn the tide. In the meantime, he is still engaged to Ying’s younger sister, Nian. The wedding keeps getting delayed but that can only last so long. She and Ye-Yang have yet to connect and she desperately wants to. She has also developed a friendship with Ye-Kan, Ye-Yang’s other brother. The story goes back and forth between the two sisters POV as we get both sides of the conflict. We also get to see how smart both of them are. Ying, has mind to create, while Nian has a mind for strategy. In a lot of ways, they are both are where they are supposed to be. As the story unfolds and we learn more about the complicated history of the clans and the politics on the Nine Isles, it is clear that not everything is black and white. I did appreciate the little bit of a cliffhanger of an ending. I don’t know if there is going to be a third book but if there isn’t. I like of leaving it open ended and up for interpretation. What’s the verdict. Not a bad a series. I liked the story but maybe the not so much the execution.